“ Staying at Clifty Falls State Park in Madison, Indiana and discovering many restaurants in town are closed on Sunday. So we decided to pick up a pizza from The Red Pepperoni. So glad we did!! Got a large RPD (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green pepper, onion). Delicious crust, flavorful sauce, plenty of toppings. Even better was Sunday is $16 large pizza night. ”

“ Food was delicious. Very generous size Italiano salad. Cheesy bread hot right out of the oven. Chicken Parm ... yummy and just the right size. Service was friendly and server was knowledgeable about the menu. Refreshing to find a server who knows the menu. Ambiance...basic...however the food was the show stealer. One definitely goes for the food. ”

“ Back again 2 years have gone by, I really believe this place is only getting better and I didn't believe that's possible. I've been devouring pizza over 60 years, this is absolutely without a doubt, in the top 3 I have ever eaten. Truthfully the care they take in putting the toppings on, is an art form. They should start a pizza school. Flavors are just as I remember or maybe even better. Get anywhere near here, you owe it to yourself to give this a try! Can't wait to get back!! ”

“ What an amazing spot to grab a pie! My husband and I stopped while traveling through Madison. We both got a side salad and I can't say enough how great the homemade dill ranch dressing was! We got a pizza with sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms and it was DELICIOUS! The service and atmosphere were also great!! if you're in Madison it's a must try!! ”

“ Quick cook time for a pizza. Really good crust, not greasy and maybe the biggest pepperoni slices ever to land on a thinish crust pizza. Good menu selections. There is inside and outside tables The parking situation is limited and dangerous if a big truck pulls in beside you. Friendly service and TV situation is good for watching games. ”

“ Delicious pizza place offering both indoor and outdoor seating. The waitstaff proved knowledgeable about the many types of pizza offered here. The pizza arrived at our table hot and tasty . A good beer selection is also available Restrooms are so so. Parking is available in front and along the side street. The ambience is very open. ”

“ I recently visited Red Pepperoni out of curiosity, and I have to say this place is fantastic! Despite it being very busy, we were served in a reasonable amount of time, which was impressive. We ordered the roasted artichoke chicken calzone, the RPD Special pizza, and the raviolis. Everything tasted great, but the calzone was especially noteworthy--it was bursting with flavor! The pizza was also excellent, with a generous size and delicious taste, and the raviolis were tasty as well. Their beer selection is impressive, featuring a good variety of Lagers and IPAs. It's perfect for anyone looking to enjoy some great pizza or just to have a few drinks. I highly recommend Red Pepperoni to anyone in the area. Will definitely be coming back! ”

“ A very cute & quaint pizza joint off of the main strip in downtown Madison. All the staff we interacted with were very nice. This was our first time visiting & we loved it! We got a pepperoni pineapple pizza with garlic sauce. The pizza was delicious - a little too greasy for my liking but I simply dabbed the pizza with a napkin & proceeded to inhale the food. We will definitely be back when the weather is warmer to experience their deck outside. It is decorated with cute market lighting & is sure to be amazing! ”